|
Helps travelers discover cave parks through mood, meaning, and practical guidance—matching destinations to curiosity, stillness, family exploration, or hidden-world adventure while offering clear tips on access, atmosphere, and respectful travel.
|
Some journeys begin under open skies. Others begin by stepping into the earth. Natural cave parks offer a different kind of travel experience — quieter, cooler, and filled with a sense of hidden time. These are places where daylight fades, sound softens, and the landscape feels ancient, protected, and almost otherworldly. For travelers seeking stillness, wonder, and a deeper connection to nature, cave destinations offer a memorable escape from the ordinary. |
The Subterranean Mirror: An Analysis of Speleological Systems, Human Chronobiology, and Ecological Management in American Cave Parks
The subterranean landscapes of North America represent a singular frontier where geological deep time intersects with human biological limits and cultural history. These systems, ranging from the sprawling epigenic labyrinths of the Kentucky karst to the hypogenic sulfuric acid cathedrals of the Guadalupe Mountains, serve as high-fidelity repositories of environmental and evolutionary data. For the speleologist, the phycologist, and the neurologist, caves offer a controlled environment—a "natural laboratory"—where variables such as light, temperature, and humidity remain remarkably stable, allowing for the isolation of specific phenomena, from the growth of invasive lampenflora to the intrinsic rhythms of the human circadian clock. This report provides an exhaustive examination of the primary natural cave parks in the United States, synthesizing their geological origins, their role in the advancement of human chronobiology, the complexities of managing their unique phycological ecosystems, and their significance as archaeological and paleontological archives.
The Geohistorical Genesis: Speleogenesis Across the American Landscape
The formation of the major American cave systems is not a monolithic process but a result of diverse chemical and physical interactions occurring over millions of years. Understanding these mechanisms is essential for interpreting the distinct morphologies encountered in parks such as Mammoth Cave, Carlsbad Caverns, and Great Basin National Park.
Epigenic Carbonic Acid Dissolution
The most prevalent mechanism for cave formation in North America is epigenic speleogenesis, a "top-down" process driven by the hydrologic cycle. In systems like Mammoth Cave National Park in Kentucky and the majority of the passages in Lehman Caves within Great Basin National Park, the primary agent is carbonic acid (H2CO3). This acid forms when meteoric water (rain) absorbs carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere and, more significantly, from the organic-rich soil layer. As this weakly acidic water percolates through the vadose zone—the aerated region above the water table—it encounters soluble bedrock such as limestone or marble.
At Mammoth Cave, this process began approximately 10 million years ago within the Mississippian-aged limestone belts that extend from Indiana through Kentucky. The resulting landscape, known as karst, is characterized by sinkholes, disappearing streams, and vast horizontal galleries carved by the slow dissolution of calcium carbonate (CaCO3). The sheer scale of Mammoth Cave—the world’s longest known system with over 400 miles explored—is a testament to the efficiency of this epigenic model.
Hypogenic Sulfuric Acid Speleogenesis
A radically different model, recognized primarily in the 1970s through pioneering work in the Guadalupe Mountains, is hypogenic speleogenesis. Unlike the top-down carbonic acid model, hypogenic caves form from the "bottom-up" as aggressive fluids rise from deep within the Earth. Carlsbad Caverns and the nearby Lechuguilla Cave are the quintessential examples of this process.
In these systems, hydrogen sulfide (H2) gas, often originating from deep-seated oil and gas deposits, migrates upward and reacts with oxygenated groundwater to produce sulfuric acid (H2SO4) This powerful acid dissolves the limestone with extreme efficiency, creating massive, high-ceilinged chambers like the "Big Room" at Carlsbad. A diagnostic feature of sulfuric acid speleogenesis is the presence of massive secondary gypsum (CaSO4 ` 2H2O) deposits, a byproduct of the chemical reaction between the acid and the carbonate rock. Evidence of similar sulfuric acid events has been identified in the Gypsum Annex of Lehman Caves, where speleogens such as rillenkarren and acid pool basins indicate a history far more complex than simple surface drainage.
The most prevalent mechanism for cave formation in North America is epigenic speleogenesis, a "top-down" process driven by the hydrologic cycle. In systems like Mammoth Cave National Park in Kentucky and the majority of the passages in Lehman Caves within Great Basin National Park, the primary agent is carbonic acid (H2CO3). This acid forms when meteoric water (rain) absorbs carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere and, more significantly, from the organic-rich soil layer. As this weakly acidic water percolates through the vadose zone—the aerated region above the water table—it encounters soluble bedrock such as limestone or marble.
At Mammoth Cave, this process began approximately 10 million years ago within the Mississippian-aged limestone belts that extend from Indiana through Kentucky. The resulting landscape, known as karst, is characterized by sinkholes, disappearing streams, and vast horizontal galleries carved by the slow dissolution of calcium carbonate (CaCO3). The sheer scale of Mammoth Cave—the world’s longest known system with over 400 miles explored—is a testament to the efficiency of this epigenic model.
Hypogenic Sulfuric Acid Speleogenesis
A radically different model, recognized primarily in the 1970s through pioneering work in the Guadalupe Mountains, is hypogenic speleogenesis. Unlike the top-down carbonic acid model, hypogenic caves form from the "bottom-up" as aggressive fluids rise from deep within the Earth. Carlsbad Caverns and the nearby Lechuguilla Cave are the quintessential examples of this process.
In these systems, hydrogen sulfide (H2) gas, often originating from deep-seated oil and gas deposits, migrates upward and reacts with oxygenated groundwater to produce sulfuric acid (H2SO4) This powerful acid dissolves the limestone with extreme efficiency, creating massive, high-ceilinged chambers like the "Big Room" at Carlsbad. A diagnostic feature of sulfuric acid speleogenesis is the presence of massive secondary gypsum (CaSO4 ` 2H2O) deposits, a byproduct of the chemical reaction between the acid and the carbonate rock. Evidence of similar sulfuric acid events has been identified in the Gypsum Annex of Lehman Caves, where speleogens such as rillenkarren and acid pool basins indicate a history far more complex than simple surface drainage.
The Human-Subterranean Interface: A Chronology of Exploration
The history of American caves is a narrative of adaptation, from the utilitarian resource extraction of indigenous peoples to the aesthetic and scientific pursuits of modern society.
Indigenous Utilization and Mineral Mining
The human history of the Mammoth Cave area is documented to have begun at least 12,000 years ago, with intensive exploration of the cave itself occurring 5,000 to 4,000 years ago. These prehistoric explorers from the Late Archaic and Early Woodland periods were not merely seeking shelter; they were sophisticated miners. Utilizing river cane torches and mussel shell scrapers, they ventured miles into the darkness to extract minerals such as gypsum (likely for paint or ritual use), mirabilite (a saline laxative), and epsomite. Artifacts such as woven fiber sandals, gourd bowls, and petroglyphs found in the cave's upper levels demonstrate a deep familiarity with the subterranean environment.
Similarly, in the Chihuahuan Desert, the Mescalero Apache and Zuni Pueblo peoples have long-standing ties to the area surrounding Carlsbad Caverns, which they referred to as the "Home of the Bat". While pictographs and mescal cooking pits at the cave entrance confirm their presence as early as 900 AD, there is no evidence that they ventured into the deeper, more dangerous passages, possibly due to the significant vertical drops at the entrance.
The Industrial and Commercial Era
In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, caves became industrial sites. Mammoth Cave was heavily mined for saltpeter, a crucial ingredient in gunpowder, particularly during the War of 1812. This labor was largely performed by enslaved African Americans, who would later become the cave’s most celebrated explorers and guides.
Stephen Bishop, an enslaved man brought to Mammoth Cave in 1838, is a central figure in American speleology. Bishop was the first to cross the "Bottomless Pit," a 105-foot chasm that had previously blocked exploration. His "prodigious memory" and "quickness of perception" allowed him to map the labyrinthine passages with a level of accuracy that amazed visiting scientists. Bishop’s legacy, along with the Bransford family of guides, highlights a period where the cave provided a unique, albeit constrained, space for intellectual achievement and "freedom" within the context of slavery.
In the West, the commercialization of caves was often driven by individual "discoverers." James "Jim" Larkin White, a 16-year-old cowboy, is credited with the first modern exploration of Carlsbad Caverns in 1898 after investigating what he thought was smoke on the horizon, only to find it was millions of Brazilian free-tailed bats exiting the cave. White’s early explorations, conducted with a handmade kerosene lantern and a wire-and-wood ladder, laid the groundwork for the site's designation as a National Monument in 1923 and its eventual transition to a National Park in 1930.
Indigenous Utilization and Mineral Mining
The human history of the Mammoth Cave area is documented to have begun at least 12,000 years ago, with intensive exploration of the cave itself occurring 5,000 to 4,000 years ago. These prehistoric explorers from the Late Archaic and Early Woodland periods were not merely seeking shelter; they were sophisticated miners. Utilizing river cane torches and mussel shell scrapers, they ventured miles into the darkness to extract minerals such as gypsum (likely for paint or ritual use), mirabilite (a saline laxative), and epsomite. Artifacts such as woven fiber sandals, gourd bowls, and petroglyphs found in the cave's upper levels demonstrate a deep familiarity with the subterranean environment.
Similarly, in the Chihuahuan Desert, the Mescalero Apache and Zuni Pueblo peoples have long-standing ties to the area surrounding Carlsbad Caverns, which they referred to as the "Home of the Bat". While pictographs and mescal cooking pits at the cave entrance confirm their presence as early as 900 AD, there is no evidence that they ventured into the deeper, more dangerous passages, possibly due to the significant vertical drops at the entrance.
The Industrial and Commercial Era
In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, caves became industrial sites. Mammoth Cave was heavily mined for saltpeter, a crucial ingredient in gunpowder, particularly during the War of 1812. This labor was largely performed by enslaved African Americans, who would later become the cave’s most celebrated explorers and guides.
Stephen Bishop, an enslaved man brought to Mammoth Cave in 1838, is a central figure in American speleology. Bishop was the first to cross the "Bottomless Pit," a 105-foot chasm that had previously blocked exploration. His "prodigious memory" and "quickness of perception" allowed him to map the labyrinthine passages with a level of accuracy that amazed visiting scientists. Bishop’s legacy, along with the Bransford family of guides, highlights a period where the cave provided a unique, albeit constrained, space for intellectual achievement and "freedom" within the context of slavery.
In the West, the commercialization of caves was often driven by individual "discoverers." James "Jim" Larkin White, a 16-year-old cowboy, is credited with the first modern exploration of Carlsbad Caverns in 1898 after investigating what he thought was smoke on the horizon, only to find it was millions of Brazilian free-tailed bats exiting the cave. White’s early explorations, conducted with a handmade kerosene lantern and a wire-and-wood ladder, laid the groundwork for the site's designation as a National Monument in 1923 and its eventual transition to a National Park in 1930.
Research at Lehman Caves using high-throughput environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding has revealed that lampenflora communities are distinct from and generally less diverse than the natural biofilm communities found on sunlit rock surfaces near cave entrances. Interestingly, many members of these lampenflora communities appear to come from unidentified sources, suggesting they may be introduced by human visitors or represent resilient niches that are difficult to manage.
Management and Mitigation Protocols
The National Park Service employs several strategies to mitigate lampenflora growth, though each has its drawbacks.
Management and Mitigation Protocols
The National Park Service employs several strategies to mitigate lampenflora growth, though each has its drawbacks.
- Light Manipulation: Experimenting with light wavelengths and replacing incandescent bulbs with LEDs has shown promise in reducing the rate of photosynthesis.
- Chemical Control: A 10% bleach (sodium hypochlorite) solution is frequently used to kill algae growth. However, this introduces foreign chemicals into a delicate environment, which can harm native troglobitic species like the blind cavefish (Amblyopsis spelaea).
- Light Deprivation: Simply keeping lights off when tours are not present is highly effective. Caves that close for the winter, such as Timpanogos Cave, exhibit far fewer phycological issues than year-round operations like Mammoth or Carlsbad.
- Operational Shifts: The proposed use of "Explorer Tours" using only hand-held flashlights or lanterns would significantly reduce the energy footprint within the cave and eliminate the primary driver of lampenflora.
Neurology and Human Performance in Subterranean Isolation
The unique conditions of the deep underground—total darkness, constant temperature, and sensory deprivation—have made caves essential sites for studying human chronobiology and psychology.
The 1938 Mammoth Cave Sleep Study
In a landmark experiment, University of Chicago researchers Nathaniel Kleitman and Bruce Richardson lived in Mammoth Cave for 32 days in 1938. Residing in Rafinesque Hall, 119 feet below the surface, they attempted to adapt to a 28-hour day (9 hours of sleep, 19 hours of wakefulness).
The study provided the first definitive evidence of an internal circadian rhythm. Richardson, aged 25, successfully adapted his body temperature and sleep cycle to the 28-hour rhythm. However, Kleitman, aged 43, was unable to adjust; his body temperature and feelings of sleepiness remained tethered to the 24-hour cycle. This established that while the human body has an internal clock independent of the sun, the ability to shift that clock varies by individual and perhaps by age.
Michel Siffre and Time Compression
French geologist Michel Siffre’s isolation experiments in the 1960s and 70s furthered this understanding. Siffre discovered "psychological time compression," where the brain's internal perception of time slows down in the absence of external cues. When asked to count to 120 (at a rate of one digit per second), Siffre would take up to five minutes to complete the task.
The 1938 Mammoth Cave Sleep Study
In a landmark experiment, University of Chicago researchers Nathaniel Kleitman and Bruce Richardson lived in Mammoth Cave for 32 days in 1938. Residing in Rafinesque Hall, 119 feet below the surface, they attempted to adapt to a 28-hour day (9 hours of sleep, 19 hours of wakefulness).
The study provided the first definitive evidence of an internal circadian rhythm. Richardson, aged 25, successfully adapted his body temperature and sleep cycle to the 28-hour rhythm. However, Kleitman, aged 43, was unable to adjust; his body temperature and feelings of sleepiness remained tethered to the 24-hour cycle. This established that while the human body has an internal clock independent of the sun, the ability to shift that clock varies by individual and perhaps by age.
Michel Siffre and Time Compression
French geologist Michel Siffre’s isolation experiments in the 1960s and 70s furthered this understanding. Siffre discovered "psychological time compression," where the brain's internal perception of time slows down in the absence of external cues. When asked to count to 120 (at a rate of one digit per second), Siffre would take up to five minutes to complete the task.
Siffre’s work also documented significant cognitive and psychological costs, including hallucinations, memory lapses (the "long day" effect), and a "slow slide into madness". These findings are now critical for NASA and other space agencies in preparing for long-duration missions to the Moon or Mars, where astronauts will face similar environments of isolation and sensory deprivation.
Hypoxia and the Neuroscience of Cave Art
Recent neurological theories suggest that the "savant-like" detail found in Paleolithic cave art may be a result of the unique environmental conditions of the deep cave. Researchers propose that ancient artists were experiencing hypoxia—a lack of oxygen—caused by the use of burning torches in deep, poorly ventilated chambers. Hypoxia can lead to the release of dopamine and the induction of altered states of consciousness, including lucid hallucinations and out-of-body experiences. This "peduncular hallucinosis" may explain why much of the most complex art is located in the most remote, difficult-to-access parts of caves, suggesting that the journey into the dark was a deliberate attempt to interact with a perceived "cosmos" through a physiologically altered state.
Hypoxia and the Neuroscience of Cave Art
Recent neurological theories suggest that the "savant-like" detail found in Paleolithic cave art may be a result of the unique environmental conditions of the deep cave. Researchers propose that ancient artists were experiencing hypoxia—a lack of oxygen—caused by the use of burning torches in deep, poorly ventilated chambers. Hypoxia can lead to the release of dopamine and the induction of altered states of consciousness, including lucid hallucinations and out-of-body experiences. This "peduncular hallucinosis" may explain why much of the most complex art is located in the most remote, difficult-to-access parts of caves, suggesting that the journey into the dark was a deliberate attempt to interact with a perceived "cosmos" through a physiologically altered state.
Subterranean Biodiversity: Extremophiles and Endemics
Caves harbor life forms that have adapted to extreme nutrient limitation and total darkness. These organisms often possess unique metabolic pathways of significant interest to biotechnology.
The Astrobiological Analogs of Lechuguilla
Lechuguilla Cave is a primary site for extremophile research. Isolated from the surface for millions of years, it contains "microbial assault weapons"—secondary metabolites produced by bacteria to compete for limited resources. These compounds have shown efficacy in killing cancer cells and malaria, representing a potential new frontier in pharmacology. Furthermore, the discovery of chemolithotrophs—organisms that derive energy from minerals rather than organic carbon—provides a model for how life might persist in the subsurface oceans of Jupiter’s moon Europa or beneath the Martian crust.
Bioluminescence and the Orfelia fultoni
Orfelia fultoni, commonly known as "Dismalites" in the context of Dismals Canyon, Alabama, is the only bioluminescent fly larva in North America. These "glowworms" inhabit damp sandstone caves and stream banks in the Appalachian Mountains and Cumberland Plateau. They emit a bright blue light ($\lambda_{max} = 460 nm$) from lanterns located at both ends of their bodies to attract prey into sticky, web-like structures. This bioluminescent system is chemically distinct from that of the famous New Zealand glowworms (Arachnocampa), as it is not activated by ATP, representing a novel biological system.
The Archaeological and Paleontological Archive
Caves act as "time capsules," preserving delicate remains that would be lost on the surface.
The Mississippian Sharks of Mammoth Cave
Recent research in the Ste. Genevieve Formation at Mammoth Cave has identified over 70 species of ancient sharks and fish from fossilized teeth and cartilage. This ocean reef environment, 340 million years old, has yielded species such as Clavusodens mcginnisi and Glikmanius careforum, a 10-12 foot shark that pushes the known origin of its genus back 50 million years.
The Gypsum Cave Controversy
Gypsum Cave, near Henderson, Nevada, is a critical site for the study of the Shasta ground sloth (Nothrotheriops shastense). Excavated in 1930, the cave yielded sloth hair, claws, and dung, initially leading archaeologist Mark Harrington to believe humans and sloths lived there contemporaneously. Modern radiocarbon dating has since clarified that the sloth remains are 11,000 to 30,000 years old, while the human artifacts date back only 3,000 to 4,500 years. The apparent association was likely a result of "biological mixing" by packrats dragging human tools into older sloth deposits.
Ancient Bat DNA in the Grand Canyon
Caves in the Grand Canyon contain bat remains preserved for up to 31,000 years. These specimens, some of which still retain skin and fur, allow researchers to sequence ancient DNA and track the effects of four million years of regional aridification on bat morphology and coloration.
The Astrobiological Analogs of Lechuguilla
Lechuguilla Cave is a primary site for extremophile research. Isolated from the surface for millions of years, it contains "microbial assault weapons"—secondary metabolites produced by bacteria to compete for limited resources. These compounds have shown efficacy in killing cancer cells and malaria, representing a potential new frontier in pharmacology. Furthermore, the discovery of chemolithotrophs—organisms that derive energy from minerals rather than organic carbon—provides a model for how life might persist in the subsurface oceans of Jupiter’s moon Europa or beneath the Martian crust.
Bioluminescence and the Orfelia fultoni
Orfelia fultoni, commonly known as "Dismalites" in the context of Dismals Canyon, Alabama, is the only bioluminescent fly larva in North America. These "glowworms" inhabit damp sandstone caves and stream banks in the Appalachian Mountains and Cumberland Plateau. They emit a bright blue light ($\lambda_{max} = 460 nm$) from lanterns located at both ends of their bodies to attract prey into sticky, web-like structures. This bioluminescent system is chemically distinct from that of the famous New Zealand glowworms (Arachnocampa), as it is not activated by ATP, representing a novel biological system.
The Archaeological and Paleontological Archive
Caves act as "time capsules," preserving delicate remains that would be lost on the surface.
The Mississippian Sharks of Mammoth Cave
Recent research in the Ste. Genevieve Formation at Mammoth Cave has identified over 70 species of ancient sharks and fish from fossilized teeth and cartilage. This ocean reef environment, 340 million years old, has yielded species such as Clavusodens mcginnisi and Glikmanius careforum, a 10-12 foot shark that pushes the known origin of its genus back 50 million years.
The Gypsum Cave Controversy
Gypsum Cave, near Henderson, Nevada, is a critical site for the study of the Shasta ground sloth (Nothrotheriops shastense). Excavated in 1930, the cave yielded sloth hair, claws, and dung, initially leading archaeologist Mark Harrington to believe humans and sloths lived there contemporaneously. Modern radiocarbon dating has since clarified that the sloth remains are 11,000 to 30,000 years old, while the human artifacts date back only 3,000 to 4,500 years. The apparent association was likely a result of "biological mixing" by packrats dragging human tools into older sloth deposits.
Ancient Bat DNA in the Grand Canyon
Caves in the Grand Canyon contain bat remains preserved for up to 31,000 years. These specimens, some of which still retain skin and fur, allow researchers to sequence ancient DNA and track the effects of four million years of regional aridification on bat morphology and coloration.
Occupational Hazards: Mental Health in the Deep Underground
The study of miners in deep underground (DUG) environments provides a cautionary tale for long-term subterranean habitation. Workers in mines at depths of 1,470 meters report significant elevations in somatization, anxiety, and paranoid ideation.
These symptoms are exacerbated by long-term shifts (over 8 hours) and are strongly associated with insomnia and fatigue. The "tunnel micro-environment" creates a nonlinear feedback loop where environmental stress leads to cognitive judgment errors, a critical consideration for both industrial safety and extraterrestrial habitat design.
Synthesis: The Future of Subterranean Science
The natural cave parks of America are more than tourist destinations; they are complex socio-ecological systems that challenge our understanding of biology, geology, and history. The management of these systems requires a multidisciplinary approach that balances public access with the preservation of fragile, millions-of-years-old environments.
Current trends in speleology are moving toward non-invasive monitoring. The use of LiDAR and photogrammetry in Lehman Caves allows for "virtual tours" that protect delicate formations from the heat and lint of human visitors. Simultaneously, the "Fluorescence Inventory" at Wind Cave is revealing hidden hydrological pathways through the chemical signatures of minerals, providing a more complete picture of cave formation than traditional mapping.
As we look toward the future, the study of caves will remain central to two disparate but equally profound human endeavors: understanding our ancient past through the archaeological and neurological secrets preserved in the dark, and preparing for our future among the stars by using the subterranean void as a surrogate for the isolation of space. The stewardship of Mammoth, Carlsbad, Great Basin, and Wind Cave is thus a responsibility that extends beyond national boundaries, protecting a record of the Earth and the human spirit that is etched in stone and silence.
Current trends in speleology are moving toward non-invasive monitoring. The use of LiDAR and photogrammetry in Lehman Caves allows for "virtual tours" that protect delicate formations from the heat and lint of human visitors. Simultaneously, the "Fluorescence Inventory" at Wind Cave is revealing hidden hydrological pathways through the chemical signatures of minerals, providing a more complete picture of cave formation than traditional mapping.
As we look toward the future, the study of caves will remain central to two disparate but equally profound human endeavors: understanding our ancient past through the archaeological and neurological secrets preserved in the dark, and preparing for our future among the stars by using the subterranean void as a surrogate for the isolation of space. The stewardship of Mammoth, Carlsbad, Great Basin, and Wind Cave is thus a responsibility that extends beyond national boundaries, protecting a record of the Earth and the human spirit that is etched in stone and silence.
National Park Service (NPS.gov) - Official Park Data
- Great Basin National Park:
- Mammoth Cave National Park:
- Carlsbad Caverns National Park:
- NPS History Electronic Library: Stephen Bishop, Cave Guide
- Smithsonian Magazine: Enslaved Tour Guide Stephen Bishop
- Discover Kentucky Archaeology: Mammoth Cave Site History
- Southern Spaces: Trying the Dark: Race and Imagination at Mammoth Cave
- University of South Florida (Digital Commons): Taxonomic Survey of Lamp Flora
- U.S. Geological Survey (USGS): Ecology of Mammoth Cave National Park
- TIME Magazine Archive: Science: Cave Men (Kleitman Study)
- Johns Hopkins University (JHU Hub): Time in Perspective: Siffre's Cave Experiments
- PubMed / NCBI: Physical and Mental Health in Deep Underground Environments
- InnovaSpace: When Time Slips: From French Caves to Mars Missions
- Dismals Canyon Official Site: Dismalites Bioluminescence
- Nevada State Historic Preservation Office: Gypsum Cave History
- The American Southwest: Geological Guide to Lehman Caves
|
Travel isn’t just about the destinations—it’s about the connections we create along the way. At Make Memories Today, I don’t just share places to visit—I bring them to life with stories that inspire, nourish, and connect us to the past, the present, and the communities that make each journey unforgettable.
®2025 Today Media Group. All rights reserved. |